Intermittent Fasting: Effective Weight Loss Tool or Fleeting Fad?
Written by Amanda Travis, MS, RD, CDN
In today's society, where a multitude of diets vie for attention, it can be challenging to discern the genuine merit of a particular program or plan. Intermittent Fasting (IF) has maintained its popularity since 2012. With over a decade in the diet scene, there is now research available that can help us answer the question: "Is it an effective eating plan or just another fleeting fad?"
A Brief Overview of Intermittent Fasting
Unlike many other diets or weight loss plans, Intermittent Fasting focuses on when a person eats rather than prescribing specific foods. There are several variations of Intermittent Fasting:
Time-Restricted Eating: This is the most popular and widely used form of intermittent fasting, involving a daily fasting window. Commonly, people fast for 12-18 hours each day. For instance, one might eat from 11 am to 7 pm and fast for the remainder of the day.
Zero Calorie Alternate Day Fasting:This method alternates between days of zero-calorie intake (complete fasting) and days of unrestricted eating, both in terms of timing and quantity. For example, someone requiring 2,000 calories daily would consume zero calories on Monday and 2,000 calories on Tuesday, repeating this pattern throughout the week.
The 5:2 Fasting Plan: This approach involves fasting with calorie intake between 0-40% of estimated daily needs for 2 days each week, while allowing unrestricted eating for the remaining 5 days. For example, someone needing 2,000 calories daily would eat a maximum of 800 calories on two fasting days and 2,000 calories on the other days.
Benefits of Intermittent Fasting
While intermittent fasting isn't suitable for everyone, those who adopt it safely and mindfully may experience benefits for both mental and physical health. Animal studies have shown that intermittent fasting can promote weight loss and improve fasting glucose levels while reducing the risk of insulin resistance. Other potential benefits may include improvements in blood pressure and memory. However, further research is needed to determine if these benefits are universally applicable to human participants.
Disadvantages of Intermittent Fasting
One of the major drawbacks of intermittent fasting is its potential to disrupt the body's internal hunger and satiety signals. Initiating intermittent fasting may require individuals to ignore their body's hunger cues during fasting periods, possibly leading to less mindful eating and perpetuating strict food rules.
Another disadvantage is how intermittent fasting is portrayed in the media. It's often advertised as an "easy" approach to weight loss, with non-fasting periods seen as times of no restrictions. However, intermittent fasting will not yield success if one overeats during non-fasting periods. A well-balanced and nutritious diet remains essential for intermittent fasting to be effective and successful for weight loss.
Like many other diets or eating plans, intermittent fasting does not substitute for physical activity. Regardless of whether you use intermittent fasting for weight loss or managing chronic conditions, no eating plan can replace the need for exercise. It's crucial to consult with a doctor before starting any fasting and/or exercise program to ensure your safety.
Other Considerations Regarding Intermittent Fasting
The first and most crucial step is to determine if intermittent fasting is a safe option for you. Start by consulting your doctor or a registered dietitian. Intermittent fasting is not suitable for individuals with a history of eating disorders, pregnant or breastfeeding women, children under 18, and people with diabetes who take medications to control blood glucose levels. Additionally, it's not recommended for individuals on medications like Mounjaro, Ozempic, and Wegovy (GLP-1 agonists) due to the appetite-suppressing effects of these medications, which can lead to inadequate calorie and nutrient intake.
Before beginning intermittent fasting, assess its sustainability as a weight loss method. If fasting is not something you can envision doing long-term, there may be better eating plans available. Several other diets or eating plans, such as the Mediterranean diet and the DASH diet, have been studied for years with proven success in improving heart health and promoting weight loss.
If you decide to pursue intermittent fasting, start with small changes to increase the likelihood of long-term success. Gradually implement intermittent fasting by beginning with a shorter fasting period, such as a 12-hour fasting window between 8 pm and 8 am. For most people, this wouldn't interfere with a three-meal-per-day plan. As you become more accustomed to intermittent fasting, you can extend your fasting period if deemed appropriate.
Conclusion
Intermittent fasting may work for some individuals, but when done incorrectly or without consideration, it can become just another fad diet, offering short-term success without lasting results. Consult your healthcare provider or a dietitian to determine the approach that best suits your needs.
Learn more about how CCA’s dietitians can help you live a healthier life.
